Here are some basic crew outlines with two names that I think fit the ship description (thanks to Ryan for the first two suggestions):
THE BELLA DONNA (means pretty lady but is also the name of a very poisonous plant)
THE SHAME OF ATLANTIS
This crew is the scum of the Pirate realm. The Captain is notorious for being absolutely ruthless and never taking any prisoners. The crew are all low lives who are only kept in line for fear of what would happen should the captain find out. They would sell their own mothers if it meant they could make a buck. They are freelooters and will attack any ship they come across be it pirate or merchant vessel.
MAKE WAVES
THE HANGMANS DUBLOON
This is a group of ex-sailors working under the queen who munity’d. They killed who ever defended the old captain but feel righteous under their new captain, the old first mate. Should they ever get caught, they will be made an example of so they are constantly on the run and very careful to keep on the good sides of Pirates so they don’t get turned in.
THE WINGS OF MERCURY
THE SCURVY SERPENT
(I was thinking about making this an NPC crew but here’s the suggestion anyway)
This ship hit a reef just off the island and it snapped the small messenger boat in half. The crew are all now searching for other crew mates, trying to get on another ship (which would require hiding that they were in the boat that split - Pirates are superstituos) or just plain petrified of the sea.
THE SCREAMING WHORE
CATS AWAY
This crew is just plain mad by Pirate standards. They pretty much accept anyone who will join, ex-slaves, women, “cursed” sailors. They are known for their general good will to captives, often offering ransom and very rarely selling as slaves. They are fiercely loyal to their captain who, in turn, treats them well.
THE TIMOROUS WENCH
HOWLING SIREN
Woman crew? I got this idea from reading a biography about Anne Bolyn. "It is known that she did thrash a young man for trying to sexually assault her, and injured him badly enough that he had to take to his bed for several weeks. Anne was around fourteen years old at the time."
Perhaps a crew that is largely made of women? They have slowly managed to collect an all-female crew. They are renouned for their intensely fierce fighting and blood thirst.
Any other ideas?